Skip to main content

Unconscious Agnostics and Atheists: The Hidden Struggle of Modern Believers

Many people who claim to believe in God are what I would call "unconscious agnostics and atheists"—or UAAs. These are individuals who, often unknowingly or without full self-honesty, don’t truly believe in God, even though they identify as Christians or faithful believers. They may attend church, serve in ministries, sing worship songs, and follow the outward practices of faith, yet when trouble comes, they don't genuinely believe that God will show up supernaturally in their lives—even after fervent prayer.

What Is an Unconscious Agnostic or Atheist?

UAAs can be found in every circle of faith—from theologians and committed church leaders to casual Sunday attendees. Many associate with the church for a range of reasons—cultural belonging, moral values, family expectations, or even social influence. Some motivations may even be selfish or harmful, contributing to negative perceptions of the church as a whole.

But being a UAA isn’t something to hide from. In fact, it's spiritually healthier to acknowledge your doubts than to suppress them. Honesty is the first step toward authentic belief.

Do You Truly Believe?

Ask yourself:

  • Do I really believe the miracles and supernatural events in the Bible as historical truth—or do I rationalize them as metaphors?

  • Is my belief rooted in personal conviction or simply a reflection of my community?

  • Do I value truth that is observable and lived, or do I accept unproven beliefs out of habit or comfort?

These are difficult but necessary questions.

Scripture on Struggling to Believe

There’s a powerful story in the Gospel of Mark where a father, desperate for healing for his child, makes a brutally honest confession:

Jesus said to him, “If you can believe, all things are possible to him who believes.”

Immediately the father of the child cried out and said with tears, “Lord, I believe; help my unbelief!” (Mark 9:23–24)

This moment reveals that even incomplete belief, when brought honestly to God, is a foundation for transformation.

Why Admitting Doubt Matters

It’s okay to struggle with belief—even while deeply wanting to believe. Most people wrestle with their faith at some point. But pretending to believe when your heart doesn't align is spiritually harmful.

Real belief begins with honesty. Once you admit your unbelief, you can ask God—just as the man in Mark did—to help you grow in faith. That’s when the real journey begins: through consistent prayer, by studying Scripture, and by testing God's promises in your everyday life.

Taking Steps Toward Authentic Faith

If you find yourself resonating with this, you're not alone. Faith is not about having all the answers; it's about seeking God with sincerity, even when your belief is shaky.

  • Start by being honest with yourself and with God.

  • Surround yourself with mentors and community who value truth.

  • Watch for the ways God shows up in your life—even in the small things.

If you’re interested, you can read my personal belief journey to learn more about how I’ve navigated faith and doubt.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

God vs Money

We live in a world currently where for most people, money is God whether or not they like to admit it. Secularism and consumerism has grown to such a extent that the pursuit of wealth and material success has become the center of people's lives. Many for the sake of accumulating money have put aside their ethics and compromised their moral values, demonstrating their idolization of money.  Conversely, many no longer place much value in organized religion and spirituality . Some Church's have been vandalized and burnt down. Attendance has declined drastically, and religious institutions hold ever lesser sway over public discourse and personal beliefs. Mans struggle throughout ones life and history has been between whether one serves either God or money. This existential conflict encapsulates the fundamental question of where one's allegiance lies: with spiritual values or material pursuits. Choosing to serve God entails prioritizing principles of faith, morality, and compas...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Lost Art of Sacrifice

In a world obsessed with comfort and self-gratification, the ancient wisdom of sacrifice stands in stark contrast to our modern mindset. Jesus's parable of the rich fool in Luke 12 serves as a powerful reminder that true abundance isn't found in what we store up for ourselves, but in what we give away. The Rich Fool's Fatal Mistake The parable tells of a wealthy man whose land produced an abundant harvest. Instead of sharing his blessing, he decided to tear down his barns to build bigger ones, telling himself, "You have plenty of grain laid up for many years. Take life easy; eat, drink and be merry." But God's response was swift and sobering: "You fool! This very night your life will be demanded from you. Then who will get what you have prepared for yourself?" This powerful story reveals God's perspective—He abhors those who selfishly hoard resources while telling themselves to take life easy. By contrast, He loves those who take life seriously a...
Post a Comment
Read more

Truth over everything

What is the most important value in the world ? Loyalty ? Faith ? Equality ? Many say prosperity. I believe the most important value is Truth. Seeking the truth for its own sake and not for any other reason. Seeking the truth about whether this life that we have right now is really all we have and death is the end of everything or is there more. Seeking out whether God is actually real. Seeking out ones purpose here on earth. These types of questions frightens many of us as it may seem near impossible to find the answer to them, however what if that is the main reason why each of us are placed here in the first place - to go on a adventure of discovery. How does one define truth? Pontius Pilate the roman prefect that oversaw the trial of Jesus Christ of Nazareth once asked Jesus "what is truth?" The dictionary defines it as "the quality and state of being true" as well as "that which is true or in accordance with fact or reality." I would add to the de...
Post a Comment
Read more